Blogs/Interviews

Accentuate the Negative, Eliminate the Positive: Why Mining Needs More Than Promises of Economic Benefits

By Sefton Darby (Independent Consultant)
Captura de pantalla 2026-11-19 a las 18.44.45.png

It has been weird, hasn’t it, to be watching the CEOs of major frontier AI labs line up over the past months to tell us that their product might in some instances actually not be awesome. I think one of the reasons why the experience has been so discombobulating is because we are so used to big companies only ever communicating about what they do in the positive. And yet along comes Dario Amodei and Sam Altman and others telling us bad things about their products.

It’s got a lot of people speculating as to what their motivations might be, and whether the ‘doomerism’ narrative around AI is understated or overstated (you can find a couple of good takes here and here), or just some peculiar marketing ploy. But AI aside, let’s return to the eccentricity of companies telling you bad things about themselves and asking for more regulation – because I think there’s something profoundly interesting in that for companies that are operating far behind the frontier that AI is on.

I have written a bit on the perils of the over-focus of companies promoting the benefits in a few places – most recently here: ‘Has the energy transition gone full Oprah?’  The TLDR of that article is this: sure, communities hosting big new mines or energy transition projects may want benefits, but they actually want a say in whether those projects should go ahead in the first place. And if you look at the evidence of what is most effective in building trust between companies and communities, it’s that they want to be listened to; for what they say to be acted on; and for companies to be effectively regulated.

The other factor that consistently eclipses the soft bribe of project benefits when it comes to building trust, is confidence that companies are identifying and managing the environmental impacts of their activities. Which is why what the AI companies are doing is so interesting, because they are at least talking about the negatives as well as the positives, as well about the role of regulation. Sure, one can be cynical about their intent, but it is still very different to most of the approaches that I see in energy, infrastructure and mining where negative impacts are brushed under the mat, benefits are oversold, and regulation is almost never talked about. 

With all of that in mind, are those seeking to improve how these more traditional sectors operate following the evidence around what builds trust – do we see the same focus on fairness, regulation, and the balance of negative and positive impacts? Well, if this recent report by Leila Kazemi and Anna Bulman is anything to go by, the answer is probably not.

The report zooms in on where global organizations are providing support around mining issues, and among a number of observations notes a ‘dramatic increase in attention to national economic development issues’ (think value addition, finance, investment, tax) and a notable decrease in funding of open governance issues (think regulations, transparency, accountability). And when I read this, all I could think of was this:

Imagen 1

 This Image by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC

 It’s a trap because focusing on the dollars starts from an assumption that all mining projects are beneficial and should or will go ahead regardless. It puts the end of the equation first rather than more difficult questions: Is this the right project? In the right place? Who is impacted? Will it be developed in the right way? By the right company? It’s a trap because it bypasses all of these questions and then lets companies engage on the exact grounds they’re most comfortable with: jobs, local procurement, building stuff. As I note in my own article:

Sure – I get it – the words ‘governance’ and ‘regulation’ make my eyelids want to take themselves off for a short nap as well. They’re not as exciting as show me the money, or follow the money, or spending the money. And as the Kazemi and Bulman report notes, donors are frustrated with looking for evidence that these kinds of programs actually work. Which is fair enough – categorically measuring the impact of governance programs is a bit like trying to nail jelly (or ‘Jell-O’ for my North American compadres) to a windmill.

The report notes that global theories of change (e.g. that transparency and participation leads to better outcomes) tend to fall apart at the national and local levels. Which is true because the political economy of how governance happens isunbelievably different – country by country, community by community. But in my mind, this is an argument in favor of throwing the ‘global’ overboard not the ‘governance’. I have long been concerned about how global governance standards are developed and negotiated in what seems like an endless stream of profiterole-fueled conferences in nice places, leading to bureaucracy and language that uniquely somehow manages to end up sounding alien to everyone.

But even if one comes at mining from an economic maximization perspective, I’d argue that all roads lead back to effective community participation and governance anyway: the evidence is that – as noted above – it’s these things that drive community trust and acceptance of mining activities, that sustain operating mines, often much more than benefits. You want nice profitable mines? Get the community and governance side right first. And doing that is going to require a lot more talking about the negatives, and a bit less talking about the positives.

Read more about the "Dialogues on Mineral Governance Funding" series.

Don't miss our latest publications Subscribe now to get our notifications